Introduction
When one cookie becomes another broken promise
Molly Carmel knew the nutrition rules and still binged in secret. Her approach to compulsive eating asks a harder question than what to eat: what happens when food becomes your most reliable source of relief?
1. My breakup with Sugar
Weight loss can leave the eating struggle untouched
Losing weight never settled Molly Carmel’s relationship with food. After reaching more than 325 pounds, she underwent gastric bypass surgery in 2000. She lost some weight, developed serious bulimic behaviors, and continued bingeing. Later, while running weight-management programs, she secretly struggled with the behaviors she treated professionally.
Her turning point came through experimenting with removing sugar and flour, alongside regular meals and support. She describes relief from constant cravings and eventually rebuilt her Manhattan clinic, the Beacon, around an addictions-based approach.
That personal history supplies the book’s central lens: examine compulsive eating beyond body size. Carmel’s experience and client testimonials explain her commitment to abstinence, though they do not establish that the same treatment suits everyone.