Introduction
Your portfolio can win while your plans fail
Beating the S&P 500 tells you surprisingly little about whether your money will fund your life. Tony Davidow examines what changes when a family’s actual obligations become the organizing principle for investing.
1. The changing industry
Cheap investments raise the bar for advice
Low-cost ETFs and automated portfolios have weakened an old advisor pitch: access to investments clients could not assemble themselves. Davidow traces the shift from commission-driven stockbroking to fees based on assets under management. That shift improved alignment, but kept the advisor’s perceived value tied to portfolio performance.
The financial crisis exposed the weakness of that promise. In 2008, the S&P 500 fell 37 percent, international markets fell 43 percent, and emerging markets fell 53 percent. Strategies marketed through recent success offered little comfort when losses spread across markets. Investors began questioning both manager selection and the fees layered above it.
An advisor using inexpensive ETFs can still provide valuable judgment about taxes or retirement funding. The challenge is making that work visible. Davidow also acknowledges a trade-off: fee pressure can reduce the research and service resources firms provide. Judge the full service and its incentives, rather than assuming either a high fee or a low fee proves value.