Introduction
Your best employees may outgrow your management
Google hired experienced executives to bring order to its chaos. They discovered that several familiar management practices would suffocate the people driving its success. Their hardest assignment became learning what to stop controlling.
Introduction
Manage the environment where smart people think
Cheap computing and abundant information give small teams powers once reserved for large organizations. Customers can compare alternatives, while builders can test ideas quickly. Under these conditions, product quality and development speed become harder to compensate for with marketing or distribution strength.
Google’s answer was the “smart creative”: someone who combines technical depth with business judgment and a hands-on approach to making things. This person might be a software engineer, but could equally be a filmmaker or doctor. The defining feature is the ability to move beyond a narrow job description and turn an insight into something useful.
Jonathan Rosenberg learned the management implications after presenting Larry Page with an elaborate product-development plan. It specified approvals and a two-year release schedule. Page rejected it, asking whether such plans ever produced products better than originally imagined. His instruction was to talk to the engineers. A predetermined process could prevent talented builders from pursuing better possibilities.
When investors later demanded a plan for competing with Microsoft, Google supplied strategic direction centered on better products rather than a detailed operating script. The leadership challenge became building an organization where smart creatives could succeed at scale. Schmidt and Rosenberg acknowledge that they also benefited from exceptional founders and fortunate timing. Their experience offers practices to test, rather than proof that copying Google guarantees its results.
Takeaway
Give talented builders a clear direction, access to information, and room to improve on the original plan.