Introduction
Yahoo’s stock soared while its business shrank
Marissa Mayer arrived with Google credentials and a company full of hope. Yahoo’s rising share price seemed to validate her turnaround, but an investment in China was concealing a much harder test.
Prologue: Bobbie Had a Nickel
A morale-saving policy becomes a trust crisis
Avoiding mass layoffs helped Marissa Mayer win Yahoo employees’ loyalty in 2012. Her alternative, Quarterly Performance Reviews, tied compensation and continued employment to ratings calibrated against a prescribed distribution. Even strong teams could be required to assign disappointing scores.
Employees began competing for ratings and resisting transfers that might disrupt their goals. Managers complained that they had to tell successful workers they had missed expectations. In November 2013, Mayer answered their anger by reading Bobbie Had a Nickel, hoping to express how much she valued her Yahoo experience. The message barely registered.
The scene introduces the central leadership tension: Mayer could improve products through exacting scrutiny, yet struggled to understand how her decisions felt to the people executing them.