Introduction
A forgotten island of nutmeg helped decide who got Manhattan
This is a story about how a tiny volcanic island called Run became one of the most valuable places on earth, because Europeans believed nutmeg could fight plague and would pay absurd prices for it. That made a remote Banda island important enough to trigger sieges, massacres, diplomatic crises, and a decades-long contest between England and the Dutch.
Giles Milton turns that contest into a vivid chain of cause and effect. You get Arctic misfires, Portuguese decline, Dutch corporate violence, English improvisation, and finally Nathaniel Courthope's doomed stand on Run. The payoff is startling: the struggle over nutmeg helped shape the bargain that left Manhattan in English hands.
Prologue and origins
Nutmeg turned a speck of rock into a world prize
Run was tiny, remote, and hard to land on, but in the early seventeenth century it mattered because it grew nutmeg. In Europe, nutmeg was not a kitchen extra. Physicians praised it as protection against plague, merchants treated it like treasure, and the markup was extreme. Milton gives the cleanest number in the book: ten pounds of nutmeg could cost less than a penny in the Banda Islands and sell in London for more than two pounds ten shillings.
That price explosion pulled Europe east. The Portuguese reached the Banda Islands first, but they never fully controlled them. They built forts elsewhere in the region, bought spice where they could, and discovered that Banda's islanders were neither passive nor easy to intimidate. The English and then the Dutch followed, each hoping to break into the trade at the source rather than buy through layers of middlemen in Venice and Constantinople.
Milton's key point is that grand historical outcomes can start with something embarrassingly small. A medicinal craze in London made an obscure island globally strategic. Once that happened, geography, monopoly, and violence took over.
Takeaway
When a commodity becomes scarce, sacred, and wildly profitable, even a tiny island can redirect the ambitions of empires.