Introduction
Why persuasion fails while false beliefs spread
People reject expert advice yet repeat bizarre rumors. Hugo Mercier examines that mismatch, challenging familiar stories about brainwashing and propaganda while asking what our mistaken beliefs actually do for us.
1. The case for gullibility
Spectacular mistakes can hide ordinary resistance
Stories about people falling for absurd claims make human gullibility seem obvious. Psychological experiments appear to confirm it: Solomon Asch’s participants sometimes endorsed visibly wrong line comparisons, while Stanley Milgram’s participants administered what appeared to be dangerous electric shocks.
Mercier challenges the inference from these cases to a general human tendency. Asch’s participants resisted the group on roughly two-thirds of the critical trials, and public agreement often concealed private disbelief. The question is what explains the pattern of acceptance and rejection across situations. Before calling someone gullible, distinguish what they publicly say from what they believe, and examine the reasons they had for trusting the source.