Introduction
Why predictability leaves you anxious and bored
You plan to avoid unpleasant surprises, then crave something that breaks the routine. Tania Luna and LeeAnn Renninger trace this contradiction through the brain and reveal how small, deliberate surprises can change ordinary experiences.
1. Surprise in the brain
Surprise interrupts your predictions and demands an update
Your brain continually predicts what will happen next. Surprise arrives when reality breaks that prediction, either through something unexpected or something “misexpected”: an outcome different from the one you anticipated. Luna and Renninger combine findings from several researchers into their own framework, the Surprise Sequence: Freeze, Find, Shift, Share.
Freeze interrupts ongoing activity and concentrates attention. Find searches for an explanation. Shift revises a schema, your mental framework for understanding something. Share draws you toward other people to tell the story and make sense of it. The initial expression may be a blank-looking “Duh Face,” rather than the theatrical open mouth people associate with surprise.
Updating a belief takes effort. Someone who meets a political opponent who defies a stereotype can dismiss that person as an exception and preserve the stereotype. Treat surprise as a cue to examine your prediction. It can open a learning opportunity, though it also intensifies unpleasant feelings and makes people feel exposed.
Takeaway
When reality surprises you, examine the expectation it contradicted before explaining the surprise away.