Introduction
Useful feedback can come from people you distrust
A rival’s criticism can contain information you need, while a friend’s encouragement can leave you stuck. Thanks for the Feedback examines what happens between hearing someone’s judgment and deciding whether to learn from it.
Three kinds of feedback
Ask for the kind of feedback you actually need
Feedback serves three different purposes: appreciation recognizes effort and encourages you, coaching helps you improve, and evaluation tells you where you stand against expectations. A conversation can go badly even when the feedback is accurate, simply because it serves the wrong purpose.
An exam grade illustrates the difference. It evaluates your performance, but it may give you almost no help with writing a better paper. For that, you need coaching: specific guidance about what to change. Equally, someone who has already worked to exhaustion may need their effort acknowledged before they can take in suggestions for improvement.
The useful move is to identify your need before asking for feedback. Tell your professor you want pointers for the next paper, rather than assuming a grade will provide them. When giving feedback, consider the recipient’s situation as well. Cheerful reassurance offers little help to someone who is struggling and needs instruction; detailed correction can feel punishing when someone is looking for appreciation.
Takeaway
Separate appreciation, coaching, and evaluation before deciding what to ask for or offer.