Introduction
A murderer in an asylum helped build the Oxford English Dictionary
The Oxford English Dictionary feels like a monument built by institutions. Simon Winchester shows it was also built by eccentrics, obsessives, autodidacts, and one deeply ill American doctor locked inside Broadmoor after a killing in Lambeth.
What makes the story stick is the collision of two lives that should never have met: James Murray, the tireless editor in his corrugated-iron Scriptorium, and William Chester Minor, a paranoid inmate whose reading and quotations became indispensable to the greatest dictionary in English.
Lambeth murder
A random killing set the whole strange story in motion
In February 1872, gunshots cracked through the night in Lambeth Marsh, one of the roughest corners of Victorian London. A brewery worker named George Merrett was walking to his shift when a stranger chased him, fired several shots, and killed him in the street. Firearms were rare enough in London that the murder instantly became a sensation.
The killer was William Chester Minor, a former surgeon-captain in the U.S. Army. He admitted firing the revolver but insisted he had shot the wrong man. He believed intruders were entering his room at night, poisoning and violating him, and that he was defending himself against one of them. At trial, police testimony, a Bethlem watcher, and Minor’s own family all confirmed the same pattern of delusions.
“You will be detained in safe custody, Dr. Minor, until Her Majesty’s Pleasure be known.”
The jury found him not guilty by reason of insanity. The judge ordered that he be held "until Her Majesty’s Pleasure be known," and Minor was sent to Broadmoor, the new asylum for the criminally insane. That sentence looked like the end of his life in the world. It became the beginning of his life in words.