Introduction
Can too much comfort weaken your resilience?
A workout stresses your body, yet recovery can leave it stronger. Physician Sharon Horesh Bergquist follows that paradox into food, temperature, fasting, and meaningful challenges, asking which discomforts deserve a place in a healthier life.
1. The stress dilemma
Modern life removed challenges our bodies still expect
Comfort has removed many of the physical demands that shaped human biology. Food is available around the clock, indoor temperatures stay steady, and movement is often optional. Bergquist identifies a second evolutionary mismatch alongside harmful modern exposures: too little intermittent, beneficial stress.
Our ancestors encountered food scarcity and bursts of strenuous activity. Their bodies adapted through protective responses that we still carry. Reintroducing selected challenges can activate those responses without recreating prehistoric hardship. Bergquist explicitly rejects treating every ancestral habit as healthy: natural selection favored reproduction, and modern sanitation and medicine have extended life.
The practical distinction is between chronic strain and a chosen, recoverable challenge. Reducing relentless pressure remains necessary. Adding manageable physical demands offers a separate route to building resilience.