Introduction
Why tomorrow’s you keeps getting a bad deal
You promise yourself more savings, better sleep, and fewer last-minute scrambles. Then today gets its way. Hal Hershfield investigates a strange possibility: the person paying for your choices may feel like someone you barely know.
1. Are we the same?
You can change without losing every thread of yourself
Your future personality will contain a mixture of continuity and change. Project Talent followed American high school students from 1960 into later adulthood. Rodica Damian, Brent Roberts, and colleagues found that roughly 40 percent showed reliable change in any given personality trait over fifty years. Being relatively shy as a teenager offered some predictive value, but no guarantee of remaining that way.
What makes someone feel like the same person through those changes? Nina Strohminger and Shaun Nichols surveyed caregivers of people with neurodegenerative disorders. Patients with ALS, which primarily damaged bodily function, seemed least changed in identity. Those with frontotemporal dementia, which can alter empathy and honesty, seemed most changed. Changes in moral character disrupted perceived identity more than memory loss did.
Hershfield opens with convicted killer Pedro Rodrigues Filho’s account of becoming committed to nonviolence, while warning that his self-report deserves scrutiny. The practical point is less dramatic: preserving valued moral commitments can provide a thread connecting you to a future self whose circumstances and interests will differ.