Introduction
Why smart investors make markets harder to beat
Wall Street’s most useful ideas came from scholars who rarely traded. Their discoveries challenged stock picking and eventually reshaped investing, but the 1987 crash exposed a dangerous gap between elegant models and markets under stress.
1. Are Stock Prices Predictable?
Make forecasters compete against a benchmark
A convincing market forecast can owe more to luck than skill. In his 1900 dissertation, Louis Bachelier described speculation as a fair game: today’s price already embodies competing expectations, so the next movement depends on information that has yet to arrive.
Alfred Cowles tested the forecasting business after the 1929 crash. His 1933 study examined thousands of recommendations, including William Peter Hamilton’s Dow Theory editorials. Following Hamilton would have multiplied an investor’s money nineteenfold from 1903 to 1929, yet buying and holding the market would have produced roughly twice as much wealth.
Hamilton’s defenders challenged the test’s interpretation and ending date. The broader lesson survives: judge advice against a feasible alternative over the same period, rather than celebrating memorable calls or impressive absolute gains.