Introduction
Good intentions are not enough
You can spend years trying to help and still do less good than someone who asks a few harder questions first. That is the uncomfortable premise of Doing Good Better: compassion matters, but evidence, trade-offs, and scale matter too.
MacAskill takes charity, career choice, ethical shopping, and public causes out of the realm of vibes and into decision-making. The payoff is startling. The gap between a decent way to help and the best way to help can be hundreds of times larger than most people think.
Introduction
The most moving idea can still be a bad intervention
MacAskill opens with the PlayPump, a charity darling that looked brilliant on paper and in photos. Children would spin a merry-go-round, the spinning would pump clean water, and villages in Africa would get both play and infrastructure at once. The project won awards, drew celebrity backing from Bill Clinton and Laura Bush, and raised millions.
Then reality showed up. The pumps were exhausting to use, often broke down, and in many villages women ended up pushing them by hand. Communities often preferred the older hand pumps, which were cheaper, easier to repair, and delivered far more water. At about $14,000 each, PlayPumps cost roughly four times as much as better alternatives.
The point is not that the backers were cynical. MacAskill grants that they were trying to help. The point is that helping others without asking what actually works can lead to waste or harm. He contrasts PlayPumps with Michael Kremer and Rachel Glennerster's work on randomized trials in development, especially deworming, where a boring intervention turned out to produce huge gains in school attendance and later income.
Takeaway
When feedback is weak and emotions are strong, the most inspiring intervention is often not the most effective one.