Introduction
Your most annoying ad might actually sell
Mr. Whipple irritated viewers and sold billions of rolls of Charmin. Luke Sullivan starts with that uncomfortable success, then tackles the harder assignment: creating advertising that sells without making people wish you would disappear.
1. Selling without selling out
Sales success leaves a question unanswered
An advertisement can sell enormous quantities and still be an idea you would hate to admit you created. Charmin aired 504 Mr. Whipple commercials between 1964 and 1990. Viewers disliked the scolding grocer, yet the brand reached number one in sales. Sullivan accepts the commercial success and challenges the creative standard it encouraged.
Bill Bernbach offered another route: respect the customer's intelligence and make the selling argument interesting. Doyle Dane Bernbach's Volkswagen ad headed “Lemon” described a car rejected for a tiny chrome blemish. An apparent weakness became evidence of exacting inspection. Strategic positioning still matters, but a sound position needs an execution people will feel and remember. Study work like Volkswagen's to learn how persuasion can retain wit and dignity, rather than treating repetition and sales figures as permission to make anything.