Introduction
Why a sincere apology can deepen distrust
You want someone who betrayed you to take responsibility. Yet their apology may make you trust them even less. Peter H. Kim’s experiments uncover the judgments that turn attempts at repair into fresh reasons for suspicion.
1. Initial trust
You already trust strangers more than you think
Trust often begins well above zero. Ordering dinner means relying on unknown cooks and a delivery driver, usually without investigating either. Kim defines trust as accepting vulnerability because you expect another person to behave well. Contracts and supervision can reduce that vulnerability, allowing cooperation even when genuine trust is absent.
In experiments with Donald Ferrin, Cecily Cooper, and Kurt Dirks, participants watched a short interview with an accountant. Despite having no independent verification of her qualifications, they expressed trust around or above the midpoint of the measurement scales. Institutional safeguards, personal dispositions, and rapid impressions can all support this initial confidence, although impressions can also carry unfair biases.
Trust can encourage people to deserve it. In Kim’s negotiation research with Tina Diekmann and Ann Tenbrunsel, participants told that their counterpart considered them ethical intended to behave more cooperatively. Giving people a chance can help create trustworthy behavior. The practical challenge is to judge more fairly while preserving the openness that makes new relationships possible.