Introduction
Building a state could not settle its identity
Zionism promised Jews refuge and the power to shape their future. Daniel Gordis follows the competing dreams behind Israel’s creation, and the conflicts that statehood transformed rather than resolved.
Poetry, politics, and homeland
An ancient attachment becomes a political project
Modern Zionism joined an inherited attachment to the Land of Israel with an urgent judgment about Europe: emancipation had failed to make Jews secure. Chaim Nachman Bialik expressed the longing in poetry; Theodor Herzl turned it into an international political movement through The Jewish State and the 1897 Basel congress.
Jewish prayers and rituals had kept Jerusalem present across centuries of dispersion. Gordis treats that collective memory as essential to understanding why Palestine commanded allegiance when other possible refuges did not.
This is a sympathetic Zionist interpretation, extending through 2016. Its central question reaches beyond Israel’s survival to how sovereignty changed Jewish life. That perspective guides its treatment of disputed events and responsibility.