Introduction
Most American history class teaches loyalty, not history
Loewen's core charge is brutal and simple: the more American history students take, the stupider they become about the American past. Textbooks flatten conflict, hide evidence, erase controversy, and turn real people into patriotic cardboard cutouts.
That matters because for most Americans, high school is the last time they study U.S. history. If the story they get is wrong about Columbus, Thanksgiving, slavery, Reconstruction, Vietnam, and the role of government, they do not just misunderstand the past. They lose the tools to understand power, inequality, racism, and democracy in the present.
Introduction
Textbooks turn history into one damn thing after another
Students hate history not because the subject is dead, but because the books are. Loewen opens with a sharp diagnosis: American history textbooks are bloated, predictable, and oddly lifeless. They pile up factoids, avoid real conflict, and present the past as a morality play where America always overcomes its setbacks and comes out fine in the end.
That style does more than bore people. It teaches students that history is a fixed list of answers rather than an argument built from evidence. Textbooks rarely use the present to illuminate the past, or the past to illuminate the present. They also suppress causation, so students memorize names and dates without learning how social life actually works.
The result, Loewen says, is not just ignorance but intellectual passivity. If five-sixths of Americans never take U.S. history after high school, then textbook history becomes civic common sense. Bad history is not a school problem. It becomes a democracy problem.
Takeaway
When history is taught as settled patriotism instead of contested evidence, students leave school less able to think about the society they live in.