Introduction
When brilliance becomes permission to behave badly
A reusable rocket can be extraordinary even when its backer posts nonsense. Helen Lewis follows the stories that turn achievement into personal superiority, asking who benefits when we decide someone deserves special rules.
Myth-making
Great work needs people to keep it alive
Shakespeare’s immortality depended on other people. John Heminges and Henry Condell preserved his plays in the First Folio; without it, eighteen works, including Macbeth, would have been lost. Later adaptations kept audiences interested by changing plots and adding spectacle. Reverence came afterwards: David Garrick’s 1769 jubilee celebrated Shakespeare without performing a single play.
Giorgio Vasari supplied another ingredient: compelling lives. His Renaissance biographies made Michelangelo the obsessive art monk and Leonardo the distracted polymath. Such portraits compressed complicated careers into memorable types. The Romantics later added madness and suffering to the template.
Lewis accepts Shakespeare’s brilliance. Her distinction concerns how talent becomes a permanent identity, supported by admirers and institutions. When assessing a reputation, ask who preserved the work and which story made its creator unforgettable.