Introduction
One convincing explanation can make you wrong
A clean explanation can hide the forces that will overturn your decision. Scott E. Page shows how different models expose those blind spots, and why disagreement between them can be useful evidence.
The many-model approach
Give competing explanations room to work
Complex problems contain several causal processes operating together. A model isolates some of them so that we can reason precisely. Its omissions make it usable and create its blind spots. Many-model thinking brings those partial explanations into dialogue.
Graham Allison analyzed the Cuban missile crisis through rational choice, organizational processes, and governmental politics. Strategic calculation helped explain Kennedy’s blockade. Organizational limits clarified military options. Domestic political pressures helped explain decisions that looked puzzling when countries were treated as single decision-makers.
Page’s REDCAPE framework gives models seven uses: reason, explain, design, communicate, act, predict, and explore. Choose models for the task, then test their assumptions against evidence. Collecting explanations merely to justify a preferred decision defeats the exercise.