Introduction
Why lost weight keeps finding its way back
Losing weight can make you hungrier while your body burns less energy. Jason Fung follows that frustrating response into a hormonal account of obesity, then asks whether changing meal timing can help.
The epidemic
An energy equation cannot explain every cause
Saying that weight gain involves taking in more energy than you expend leaves a deeper question unanswered: what drives that imbalance? Fung distinguishes the proximate cause from the ultimate cause, much as describing a plane’s insufficient lift tells us little about the mechanical failure behind a crash.
His historical example is William Banting, who reported losing weight after avoiding sugary and starchy foods in 1863. Later, official advice shifted toward reducing fat. Fung connects that shift with increased refined-carbohydrate consumption, although the timing alone cannot establish causation.
Inheritance complicates personal-blame explanations too. Albert Stunkard’s study of 540 Danish adoptees found that their weight resembled their biological parents’ more closely than their adoptive parents’. Genes help explain individual susceptibility; they cannot explain an epidemic developing within one generation.