Introduction
Your favorites know less than you think
You trust your taste to tell you who you are. Yet a label can change a flavor, a crowd can manufacture enthusiasm, and your favorite song may owe its appeal to something you never registered.
Introduction: Favorites
A favorite is a moving target
Your favorite color sounds like a simple fact about you, until someone asks why your car is a different color. Tom Vanderbilt’s five-year-old daughter asks exactly that. His answer reveals how preferences depend on categories: liking blue does not mean wanting blue everywhere. His red trousers, appealing when he lived in Spain, stayed in a drawer after he moved to New York.
Even apparently basic preferences carry histories. Psychologists Stephen Palmer and Karen Schloss propose ecological valence theory: people tend to like colors associated with things they like. Blue evokes clear skies and clean water; brownish yellow often evokes unpleasant substances. Berkeley and Stanford students preferred their own university’s colors, with stronger school attachment accompanying stronger color preference. These findings support an account based on learned associations, although they do not settle how much biology contributes.
We also construct answers when asked. Vanderbilt offers eight as his favorite number, then searches for a reason. Psychologist Timothy Wilson’s concept of the adaptive unconscious helps explain this gap: we experience a feeling without access to the processes producing it, then supply a plausible explanation. Treat a declared favorite as information about a person in a particular setting, rather than a permanent readout of an inner self.