Introduction
Civilization may have needed a buzz
Most books about alcohol ask whether drinking is bad for us. Edward Slingerland asks a stranger question: why did humans ever want to get drunk in the first place, and why did that urge survive if intoxication is so costly?
His answer flips the usual story. Alcohol is not just an evolutionary mistake or a guilty pleasure. It helped human beings solve problems that came with becoming intensely social, creative, culture-building primates. If that is even partly true, then arguments about drinking, work, religion, ritual, pleasure, and public health need a very different starting point.
The puzzle
Drunkenness is too costly to be a mere accident
The usual scientific story treats alcohol like porn or junk food: a reward-system hack. Either ethanol accidentally picks the brain's pleasure lock, or our taste for it is an evolutionary hangover from a world where tiny amounts in ripe fruit were useful. Slingerland thinks both stories are too weak. Alcohol is a toxin. It impairs judgment, damages the body, fuels violence, and has been doing so for thousands of years.
That cost matters. If drunkenness were just a mistake, evolution and culture should have moved hard against it. Humans adapted quickly to drinking milk as adults, to living at high altitude, and to other new pressures. Cultures also solve practical problems fast. If alcohol were mainly about preserving calories, disinfecting water, or adding nutrients, porridges, boiling, and other safer solutions should have displaced it.
Instead, humans keep brewing, fermenting, trading, and ritualizing intoxicants nearly everywhere. Even cultures without alcohol reliably substitute something else, like kava, cannabis, or hallucinogenic tobacco. That persistence turns intoxication into a real evolutionary puzzle, not a moral lecture.
Takeaway
A behavior this ancient, widespread, and costly probably survived because it solved important human problems.