Introduction
Can you defend morality without cosmic backup?
You can reject cruelty and still struggle to explain why anyone must agree with you. Simon Blackburn follows that discomfort through religion and human nature, asking how moral confidence can survive without an ultimate guarantee.
The death of God
Authority cannot make a command good
A divine command still faces a moral question: does God approve something because it is good, or does approval make it good? Plato’s Euthyphro exposes the difficulty. If divine commands answer to goodness, we need standards by which to understand that goodness. Sheer power cannot supply them.
Blackburn’s example is betrayal. Someone who avoids betraying a friend only after calculating the risk of divine punishment has missed the moral reason: it would betray the friend’s trust. Fear can produce obedience without producing virtue.
Religion can preserve moral imagination through stories, and it can lend authority to oppression. When believers accept some passages and reject others, they already exercise moral judgment. Losing religious certainty therefore leaves ethical work to do, rather than making that work impossible.