Introduction
What a Rolex and a Threat Have in Common
An expensive watch, an angry stranger, and an attractive alternative can pull behavior in unexpected directions. Douglas Kenrick traces these reactions to ancestral pressures whose influence often escapes our awareness.
Attraction and commitment
The people you look at can change your standards
Attraction depends partly on the alternatives occupying your attention. In an experiment by Douglas Kenrick and his colleagues, men reported lower commitment to their partners after viewing beautiful women. Women reported lower commitment after exposure to socially dominant men. The pattern suggests that judgments about an existing relationship can shift when apparently desirable alternatives become mentally available.
Kenrick connects these findings to ancestral mating pressures. In his evolutionary account, female beauty and male social dominance served as cues to desirable partners, although the experiment itself measured present-day responses rather than ancestral behavior. The distinction matters: an evolutionary explanation offers a proposed reason for a pattern, while the observed result concerns how participants rated their commitment after a particular exposure.
A university anecdote makes the comparison effect more tangible. Kenrick thought his campus was full of beautiful women, while an average-looking friend who struggled to get dates disagreed. Visiting the friend's room, Kenrick found walls covered with Playboy centerfolds. He interpreted those images as an unrealistic comparison standard that made ordinary potential partners seem less attractive. The practical implication is to question the comparisons feeding dissatisfaction. Constant exposure to unusually attractive or high-status people may alter how you judge the partner you have, or the people you might realistically date.
Takeaway
Before treating dissatisfaction as a verdict on your relationship, consider which alternatives have been shaping your comparisons.