Introduction
When your happiness becomes someone else's business
At Davos in 2014, corporate leaders meditated and tracked their bodies. William Davies traces how this concern for well-being grew from a much older ambition, with uncomfortable consequences for whose unhappiness gets heard.
1. Knowing How You Feel
Measuring happiness changes who gets to define it
A government devoted to happiness still needs someone to decide what happiness means. Jeremy Bentham proposed maximizing pleasure and minimizing pain across society, treating everyone's suffering as worthy of consideration. His ambition combined genuine empathy with distrust of political language: rights and justice seemed too abstract to provide reliable guidance.
The difficulty was measurement. How could officials compare the intensity of one person's pleasure with another's pain? Bentham tentatively suggested two proxies: pulse rate and money. These suggestions anticipate the bodily monitoring and economic valuation that run through the modern well-being industry.
Gustav Fechner made the measurement project experimental. From 1855, he lifted subtly different weights to test the relationship between physical changes and subjective sensation. His unit, the “just noticeable difference,” helped establish psychophysics. Unlike Bentham, Fechner retained a metaphysical understanding of mind, while seeking mathematical relationships between mind and matter.
Davies's objection concerns the authority these measurements acquire. Someone describing herself as angry may be making a considered judgement about injustice. An expert who responds by reducing her unpleasant feelings can miss her meaning entirely. Before accepting a happiness score as a guide to action, ask whether it leaves room for the person's reasons and demands.
Takeaway
A measure of distress cannot, by itself, tell us whether to change someone's feelings or the circumstances causing them.