Introduction
Knowing your subject can make writing worse
Expertise can hide the very details your reader needs. Steven Pinker traces why clear thoughts become tangled prose, and why some familiar grammar rules make the damage harder to repair.
1. Good writing
Read good sentences like someone who builds them
A writer’s ear develops through attentive reading. Accomplished writers absorb patterns from other writers, often without having consulted a style manual. Pinker makes that apprenticeship deliberate: linger over a passage that works and reverse-engineer its effects. Ask what the opening makes you expect, which details create an image, and how the rhythm supports the meaning. Learning to write can begin with pleasure rather than fear of breaking rules.
Richard Dawkins opens Unweaving the Rainbow by calling people lucky because they will die. The apparent contradiction creates curiosity; the explanation makes existence itself seem improbable and precious. Rebecca Newberger Goldstein takes a different route in Betraying Spinoza. A childhood photograph, including a girl struggling to fit watermelon into her mouth, gives the philosophical problem of personal identity a visible form. These passages show how different voices can make difficult ideas graspable.
Margalit Fox’s obituaries demonstrate the value of carefully chosen adjectives and playful wording. Describing Maurice Sendak’s books as occasionally eaten brings their young readers into view while gently teasing adult censors. Blanket advice to avoid unusual words or modifiers would sacrifice such effects. Pinker recommends a dictionary and permits a thesaurus, provided the writer chooses words for precise meaning rather than display.
Isabel Wilkerson restores individual decisions to the abstraction called the Great Migration. Typists want office jobs; yard workers fear lynching. After describing the pressures on those lives, she ends with the two-syllable paragraph “They left.” Its force comes from its placement. The practical habit is to study how wording and structure direct attention, then borrow the technique without copying another writer’s voice.