Introduction
What gets lost when we name nature?
Two eighteenth-century rivals tried to catalogue every living thing. Their disagreement over what a name could tell us helped shape modern biology, while giving human prejudices an enduring scientific disguise.
Two beginnings
A botanical obsession meets an inherited fortune
Carl Linnaeus and Georges-Louis Leclerc, later known as Buffon, were both born in 1707. Their routes into natural history could hardly have differed more. Linnaeus, a Swedish pastor’s son intended for the ministry, performed so poorly at school that his teachers recommended a manual trade. A physician recognized his botanical knowledge and redirected him toward medicine.
Linnaeus nearly starved at university before Olof Celsius offered him food and lodging. Buffon’s independence came through an unexpected childhood inheritance, freeing him from his father’s hated occupation collecting France’s salt tax. Roberts establishes how much inquiry depended on access to money and patrons. Neither man’s eventual authority followed straightforwardly from academic achievement.